| Cards | Rating | |
|---|---|---|
| Pepe Reina | 6 | |
| Jamie Carragher | 7 | |
| Martin Skrtel | 8 | |
| Jose Enrique |  | 7 |
| Martin Kelly | 8 | |
| Steven Gerrard | 9 | |
| Stewart Downing | 7 | |
| Jay Spearing | 7 | |
| Jordan Henderson | 7 | |
| Andy Carroll | 7 | |
| Luis Suarez | 8 | |
| Substitutes | ||
| Alexander Doni | ||
| Sebastian Coates | ||
| John Flanagan | ||
| Maxi Rodriguez | ||
| Jonjo Shelvey | ||
| Charlie Adam | ||
| Dirk Kuyt * | 6 | |
| Cards | Rating | |
|---|---|---|
| Tim Howard | 6 | |
| Phil Jagielka | 6 | |
| Sylvain Distin | 6 | |
| Leighton Baines | | 7 |
| Tony Hibbert | | 6 |
| Seamus Coleman | 5 | |
| Steven Pienaar | | 6 |
| Jack Rodwell | 5 | |
| Marouane Fellaini | 6 | |
| Victor Anichebe | 6 | |
| Denis Stracqualursi | 5 | |
| Substitutes | ||
| Jan Mucha | ||
| John Heitinga | ||
| Phil Neville | ||
| Leon Osman * | 5 | |
| Royston Drenthe ** | | 6 |
| Tim Cahill | ||
| Nikica Jelavic *** | 6 | |
